Last week I attended the Queensryche concert in Denver at the Gothic Theater. It was the Queensryche version with Geoff Tate but none of the other members of the band. I went with an old buddy from High School who has actually played the same venue when he was the lead guitarist of a local Denver band. We both thought that the show was pretty good (they played Operation Mindcrime end-to-end along with a few songs from Empire). Operation: Mindcrime is my all-time favorite alum and hearing Tate sing it was pleasantly nostalgic. My musician-buddy felt that the new lineup executed the album faithfully and we both agreed that we got our money’s worth from the show.
You may or may not know this, but there are now two Queensryche’s. One has Geoff Tate but not the rest of the band (Queensryche 1.x), and the other (Queensryche 2.0) is fronted by a very Tate-sounding lead singer. Queensryche 1.x released “Frequency Unknown” – one of the worst albums I’ve heard from any band, much less Queensryche. Conversely, Queensryche 2.0 released “Queensryche” which is the best Queensryche Album since 1994’s Promised Land. (I’ve reviewed this album and expressed my disgust with Frequency Unknown here.)
As I stood listening to Operation: Mindcrime live I had a thought occur to me. “This is good enough.” As a matter of fact even if no original members of Queensryche were there I’d have been happy enough.
This next question might seem out-of-nowhere…but I will come back to Queensryche in a second.
Have you ever seen Trans-Siberian Orchestra live?
A few years ago my wife bought me tickets to TSO for my birthday – which is near the holidays. We saw them in a massive arena venue and for the first half of the show (which is dominated by Religiosity) I was wondering “Why the hell am I here?” (After all, I’m an Atheist.) Then the second half of the show was all instrumental and was one of the most fun-filled metal-eque performances I have ever seen! Flames spewing out of the floor, lights, hair flying, electric guitar solos…It was awesome! I went in barely knowing who TSO was, and I left a fan.
I did a little reading on TSO and discovered that there is not ONE Trans-Siberian Orchestra, there are MANY. That is how they are able to play so many cities so near the holidays. They have essentially cloned themselves.
Here it comes…
Queensryche should do the same. The status quo of two Queensryche’s is not only sustainable, but might even be desirable for the fans.
What if being “Queensryche” didn’t refer to 5 individuals, but a set of artistic and musical guidelines. Maybe it could be defined as: Guitar-driven, progressive metal, that makes you think. Maybe there doesn’t need to be restrictions on future studio projects, but just a sharing of the past catalog of music. When I was at the concert and looked around the Gothic Theater it appeared that everyone knew the words to every song. None of them were there to hear something new…and a majority had T-shirts from tours gone by. It was interesting to note that not a single song was played from Geoff Tate’s despicably bad album “Frequency Unknown”.
What if a state of two competing Queensryches was the new norm and they both competed to produce better product?
I’m perfectly content to see different people on stage than the people who produced a studio album, provided both are quality.